Home
Services
Incorporations Trademarks Buying/Selling a Business Corporate Governance Corporate Reorganization Mergers & Acquisitions Securities Shareholder Agreements Partnership & Joint Venture Agreements Lease Agreements Franchise Agreements Buy-Sell Agreements Employment Contracts Contract Negotiations Employment & Labour Civil Litigation Small Claims MSB Registration / FINTRAC RPAA Registration / Bank of Canada Dental Law Blockchain Law
Lawyers
All Lawyers Keely McConnell Raveena Basra Perpinder Patrola Simon Joo AboutBlogFAQ Book a Free Consultation
Call (778) 565-4700 Book a Free Consultation
Intellectual Property

Absurd Retraction Demand from IMAX in the name of Trademark Infringement

By Perpinder Patrola
Absurd Retraction Demand from IMAX in the name of Trademark Infringement

Absurd Retraction Demand from IMAX in the name of Trademark Infringement

On June 16, 2015, Ars Technica received a retraction demand from IMAX, requesting Ars to retract a published story that contains a brief reference to IMAX. In a letter written to Ars, IMAX’s Deputy General Counsel G. Mary Ruby wrote: “Any unauthorized use of our trademark is expressly forbidden.”

The letter is surprising in several ways. First of all, the published article is not about IMAX, but the newest version of a virtual reality system called SteamVR made by Valve Software. Second, the single reference to IMAX is simply a comparison between IMAX and SteamVR, which attempts to show that the experience with SteamVR is as great as having an IMAX theatre at home.

Nevertheless, IMAX apparently did not view such a comment as a compliment, but instead as an act of trademark infringement.

IMAX’s reaction is absurd in a sense that they believe trademark owners are entitled to control and censor any speech about their products. The reality is, however, standard trademark law determines trademark infringement only by detecting whether there would be a “likelihood of confusion” between two products. The standard would apply if Ars starts selling movie tickets, leading to confusion among consumers. However, nobody will confuse reading an article about SteamVR with watching a movie.

It is important for trademark owners to understand what trademark law protects. Trademark law provides protection only for distinctive marks to avoid confusion between products and services. It does not, by any means, give trademark owners right to control or silence people’s speech.

To learn more about trademark law, please feel free to contact Patrola Law Corporation at (778) 565-4700.

Source: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/06/from-quote-to-retraction-request-imaxs-absurd-attempt-to-censor-ars/

What Clients Say

"Patrola Law helped us obtain MSB registration in Canada with FINTRAC and continues to help us stay in good standing. We depend on them as a trusted business partner."

Bryan W.
B-Liquid Cryptos

"From the initial consultation to finalizing every document, Patrola Law demonstrated real professionalism setting up our company in Canada."

Kehinde M.
Starks Associates

"Quick turnarounds, professional advice, great communication, and no hidden costs on our MSB registration."

Lu Q.
Quan Media

"Sundeep made our estate plan painless and explained every option in plain English."

R. Bhatt
Client, estate planning

Ready to move at startup speed?

Book a free 15-minute consult and get a straight answer within one business day.

Book a Free Consult (778) 565-4700